Blog · Mixing and mastering

How to give mix feedback: a guide for musicians and bands

· 3 min read · Nimora team

Puesto de mezcla del estudio

You receive the first mix of your song and know you want something changed, but “it needs more power” does not explain where the problem is. Useful feedback turns that impression into a note the engineer can locate, interpret and discuss with you. You do not need to know plugins: you need a listening method and organised notes.

1. Identify the version before listening

Write down the filename and use that version throughout your review. If band members comment on different files, a request may concern something already fixed. A simple label such as Song_mix_02 avoids confusion. Keep the previous version for comparison too.

2. Listen to the whole song first

Play the song from start to finish without stopping. Note which section moves you, where your attention drifts and whether the main element comes across. Focus on the direction of the song: a slightly brighter guitar can wait if the chorus does not yet convey what you intended.

Then return to specific moments. Use a familiar playback system at a comfortable volume; when comparing versions, try to match their perceived level. Other headphones or speakers can provide another perspective, but record where you hear each issue so that observations from different setups do not get confused.

3. Specify the time, element and desired result

A clear note says when it happens, what you hear and what you would like to hear. “At 1:12, as the chorus starts, the vocal loses clarity behind the guitars; I would like to understand the lyrics without losing energy” gives more direction than “turn up the vocal”.

You do not need to prescribe an EQ setting or an amount of compression. Describe the musical result and let the engineer suggest how to achieve it. If the change should apply to every chorus, say so explicitly.

Nimora mixing workspace with studio monitors and audio equipment
The mixing workspace at Nimora.

4. Put requests in priority order

Separate essential changes from adjustments you would like to try. An unclear word, a cut-off entrance or a missing instrument needs a precise description. A longer effect or a closer vocal may be a creative preference. Explain what already works too: “keep the character of the drums” helps preserve a decision you like.

If the whole band is involved, collect everyone’s feedback in one document. Resolve contradictory requests before sending it. You do not need special software: a shared list with timestamps and named contributors is enough.

5. Use references to communicate one idea

If you include another song, specify what it illustrates: an intimate vocal, a wide chorus or the drum ambience. Asking two different productions to sound identical leaves too many decisions open. A reference explains an intention while taking your song’s arrangement and recordings into account.

A short mix feedback template

File: Song_mix_02.
Priority: high.
Time: 1:12–1:28, first chorus.
Element: lead vocal.
Observation: the ends of phrases are hard to understand.
Goal: improve clarity while keeping the guitars energetic.
Keep: the character of the drums.

Before approving the mix

Check the changes in the new version and listen to the whole song again, including the beginning and final tail. Confirm in writing which file you approve. Agree the scope and number of revisions with the studio before starting: this guide does not set Nimora’s commercial revision policy.

If you are still preparing your files, read how to send tracks for mixing. For the next stage, see the difference between mixing and mastering.

Want to work on your next song with Nimora? Explore our recording studio in Valencia and tell us about your project so we can agree how to prepare and review the mix.

Nimora · Paterna (Valencia, Spain)

Shall we record your next song?

Tell us what you want to record, how many of you there are and which dates suit you. We will reply on WhatsApp or by email.