It is one of the first decisions a band makes in the studio: do we all play together, like at a gig, or record instrument by instrument? Both approaches work and each has its advantages. Here is when each one makes sense.
Recording track by track
First the foundation is recorded (usually the drums, sometimes with a guide guitar and vocal), and then the bass, guitars, vocals and details are added on top. Each musician records their part separately.
Advantages
- Full control: a part can be redone without the whole band playing again.
- A cleaner sound, with no instrument bleeding into another’s microphone.
- More room in the mix to edit and adjust each element.
Disadvantages
- You have to play to a metronome or a guide, and not everyone is used to it.
- Some of the energy of playing together can be lost.
It is the most common approach in modern rock, metal and pop, where a precise, punchy sound is the goal.
Recording live
The whole band plays at the same time in the studio, like in the rehearsal room. Some parts (almost always the vocals) can be re-recorded afterwards, or details added.
Advantages
- It captures the band’s energy and interplay.
- It can be quicker if the band is very tight.
- It sounds more natural and organic.
Disadvantages
- One mistake means redoing the whole take.
- Less room for editing in the mix.
It works really well in styles where the performance is everything: blues, classic rock, jazz, folk or bands with lots of live experience.

The mixed option
Many bands combine both: they record drums, bass and rhythm guitar together to keep the drive, then add vocals, solos and arrangements separately. It is a good middle ground if you want energy without giving up control.
How to decide? If you have never played to a click and your strength is playing live, try live or mixed. If you want a modern, very precise sound, go track by track.
What really matters: arriving prepared
Whatever you choose, preparation is what shows most. Go over our guide on how to prepare your band before recording.
At Nimora, our recording studio in Valencia, we record both ways: track by track or with the band playing together. If you are not sure, we talk it over before the session and choose what suits your songs best. Get in touch.



